Sunday, February 15, 2009

Earth As Art

   "Image courtesy of USGS National Center for EROS and NASA Landsat Project Science Office"

This is definitely one of the coolest sites I've ever seen.  The Earth as Art.

Saturday, February 14, 2009

Games for Change

Video and computer games have a bad rep.  Yes, there are some strangely violent games out there, but there's some pretty good ones too.  And there have been some positive effects of video games found, such as improved problem-solving skills, and enhanced perceptual and cognitive skills.  (Having watched my brother, Master Gamer, for years, I quite believe this to be true.)

But I wanted to highlight another type of computer game, a movement toward using them for social change.  I say, if they are the hook that draw the kids in, that's fantastic.  

Here's the Games for Change site.  It's got quite a few on there.  The list grows every time I check back.  Free Rice is strangely addicting, Against All Odds can actually be pretty tricky.  

Excellent News

Youtube is working on allowing an option for contributors to add a Creative Commons license to their uploads.  Which means you can download videos to your computer and use them offline.  Which means a wider range of educational applications.  

What does literature say about the era in which it was written?

More on Historical Inquiry

Some recommended websites:
Great information for teachers and students on evaluating propaganda.

Offers a case study for the process of historical inquiry through the story of Martha Ballard.

Nice site for teachers seeking to incorporate historical inquiry into their classrooms.

Cool sites.  Some frivolous stuff, but also some good stuff for ideas for classroom inquiry. 

And, the best for last:

...And another word on textbooks

So this link includes a defense of textbooks in the history classroom as a major part of the article.  
Most textbook critics concede that textbooks are a necessary tool in history education. Arguments for textbook-based curricula point out that history teachers require resources to support the broad scope of topics covered in the typical history classroom. Well-designed textbooks can provide a foundation on which enterprising educators can build other classroom activities.
Sam Wineburg, a professor history and education at Stamford, has written on historical thinking.  In Historical Thinking and Other Unnatural Acts, he writes, "Textbooks dominate history classrooms, and, as Peter Schrag has noted, history textbooks are often written "as if their authors did not exist at all, as if they were simply the instruments of a heavenly intelligence transcribing official truths.""  

So I can't buy the argument either that textbooks are needed to supplement the teacher's knowledge of history.  For one, there are massive amounts of information online, much of it available for free, the use of which frees up a lot of resources that could be better spent in the classroom.  As I see it, one of the responsibilities of teachers is to be continuous learners themselves.  So that means constantly expanding their own knowledge base, learning about that which they seek to teach.  There are many ways to do this, and using textbooks as the "foundation" is not the only way, nor do I think it's the best way.

I'm not arguing to abolish textbooks either.  I'm arguing for the marginalization of them.  They should have a place in the classroom, as yet another reference.  Perhaps as a springboard for discussion on how history is "decided upon," or how biases color historical representations, or the nature of truth in history.  And so on.  

I have a history textbook from my last college survey course on early American history.  Called Give Me Liberty! An American History, it was published in 2005, authored by Eric Foner, and covers U.S. history "up to 1877."  Let's look at an example within this book.

Roanoke Colony: One blurb, one page:
"...Raleigh dispatched a fleet of five ships with some 100 colonists (many of them his personal servants) to set up a base on Roanoke Island, off the North Carolina coast, party to facilitate continuing raids on Spanish shipping.  But the colonists, mostly young men under military leadership, abandoned the venture in 1586 and returned to England.  A second group of 100 settlers, composed of families who hoped to establish a permanent colony, was dispatched that year.  Their fate remains a mystery.  When a ship bearing supplies arrived in 1590, the sailors found the colony abandoned, with the inhabitants evidently having moved to live among the Indians.  The word "Croaton," the Indian name for a nearby island or tribe, had been carved on a tree." (p.32)

That's it??  A history mystery?  What's cooler than that?  

First of all, Croatoan (the correct spelling) wasn't carved on a tree, it was carved on a fence post, on the tree appeared "Cro."  No bones, no corpses.  The boats and cannons were missing.  The book makes no mention of Manteo, raises no questions.  Well, did anybody go check out the island back then?  (John White tried to.  A hurricane hit the Outer Banks and damaged the fleet sufficiently.  They decided to return to England.)  There are great maps, images, and documents that could be used to explore this mystery.  Why not look at John Lawson's book and Hamilton MacMillan's pamphlet on this?  

Maybe my biggest beef here is semantic in nature.
"Their fate remains a mystery. When a ship bearing supplies arrived in 1590, the sailors found the colony abandoned, with the inhabitants evidently having moved to live among the Indians."
Evidently? 
ev·i·dent·ly
1 : in an evident manner : clearly , obviously
2 : on the basis of available evidence
Really?  Actually, no.  Nothing has been firmly established on the basis of evidence.  There are, however, multiple hypotheses.  And again, with the finite representation of history.  You'd never know people are still trying to figure this out.
 
There is an ongoing DNA project to try to determine lineage of the colonists (which I'll grant the author, project started the year the book was published.).  There have been remote sensing projects to try to locate the remnants of the colony.  Only fairly recently have there archaeological examinations of the region.  And I would definitely talk about the controversy over the Eleanor Dare stones. 


...historical thinking and inquiry learning...

Historical thinking is inquiry based. Historians work by asking questions, seeking answers, researching, examining, finding discrepancies, looking for patterns, making connections, developing interpretations, debating, and so on.

This was never my own experience in the history classroom. “Learning” was to take place by reading the assigned chapters and answering the often inane questions at the close of the chapter. Memorizing dates, names, places. And no, I do not remember the dates of all the battles of the Civil War, as I was tested on one day in history during high school. Not one primary document crossed my line of sight until years after I finished college.

I had to take a U.S. history survey course about a year ago, as a prerequisite for certification. Much to my disappointment, I found myself once again in a classroom curriculum chained to the textbook. No primary documents. No questions. No real discussion.

I had finally become interested in history on my own, through genealogy research and luck in who I met and worked with. Certain pieces of history, sometimes lost in the cracks, tended to interest me the most. The hunt of family research, the frustration of the brick wall (What in the world possessed the Irish to burn their records?), the looking for answers and finding them, and sometimes NOT finding them. The digging through census records and military files and old photographs and immigration records.  What finally drew me in to a subject I had long abhorred? The inquiry, of course. The process, the discovery, the joy in finding some hidden tidbit and the ever-growing list of questions that accompanied each discovery. This is of course, how history learning should look.

I’m still working out how this will look in my classroom, and don’t expect to ever have a definite answer. It’s hard to decide what works best before being in the classroom, of course, but even once there I suspect I will be tweaking my methods for years to come. The plan, as it stands now, is to have an integrated classroom that teaches across disciplines using social studies as the anchor. A big part of this means making resources available to my students to explore, and I’ve actually started doing that already: compiling my own resources, book lists, websites, primary documents, articles, lesson ideas, lists of good digital archives, and so on. The materials of exploration.

All of this requires our expectations for our students to be high.  Sometimes, out of a desire to protect our society's children, as parents and teachers, our expectations are much to low, in the name of "protecting them," or based on a too stringent view of "developmental appropriateness."  I can't tell you how many times I've heard, "They're not ready for that," "That was an exceptional group of students that did that, wouldn't work with most kids," "They can't handle it."  Simple self-fulfilling prophecy at work here.  And yet we lament the lack of critical thought or reflection.  How will they develop those skills with no practice?  It's as foolish as waiting till your kid is 10 before putting him on a bike. Surely, he's "ready" now, yes?  And then being surprised when he can't just pick up and ride off.  

Take a look at this site, CUNY's "Investigating U.S. History."  It's a series of lesson modules into American history designed for college level students.  Take a look at some of the objectives under each section.  Why couldn't these objectives be the same for elementary students?  In the lesson on labor unrest during the Depression, for example, the objectives include: 

"To stimulate an analysis of issues and events from a variety of perspectives."
"To provide an opportunity to investigate the rise of organized labor and spread of industrial democracy as both a response and a spur to Roosevelt's New Deal."
"To offer a structured way to interrogate and utilize primary sources."

Sounds good to me.  The results will be different (hopefully!) between a college level lesson and a fifth grade lesson on it, but there's no real reason why elementary students can't engage in this higher level of thinking.  

As I see it, this is one of the most important skills we can give our kids.  You'd never know it by looking at how students and schools are held accountable, or by observing the all-too-common sidelining of social studies in elementary classrooms.  Historicalthinkingmatters.org lays out pretty well why this is so important.  (Click link on that page for pop-up video introduction.)

Friday, February 13, 2009

More on Web 2.0

Classroom 2.0:
Social networking for teachers interested in using Web 2.0 technologies in their classrooms.
Make your own social networking group, allows for a "private" option making it useful for creating a community around the students (and possibly their families).  Blogs for each user, photos, discussion forums, and events calendar.  Pretty cool.
Allows for collaboration on one word document, password protected.  Great for shared writing projects.
Really, really, really easy way to create a quick website.  Definitely helpful if you're crunched for time.
Add photos, notes, videos, and more to a map.  Good for documenting local history projects, field trips, walking tours...


Sunday, February 1, 2009

Dust off those Manuscripts...

You walk down the stairs and greet the librarian. She hands you the sign in sheet, where you list just about every detail of your life. You lock up your belongings. She hands you gloves, and shows you to a table. The room is strangely lit, and rather airless. Up come the boxes. The archival material.

Papers. Photographs. Books. So old it seems they just might crumble at times. But how exciting! To be right in the thick of history, instantly transported back to the moment when the letter was written or the photograph shot. No longer a passive consumer of history, but a new kind of participant, someone who has touched and seen it with their own eyes.

That’s the beauty of primary sources, of course, something we often talk about using in education, but rarely do. It used to be difficult. Field trips to the archives wouldn’t exactly be tittilating for students, and the archivists might have an MI.

The beauty of the Internet today is that those dusty old papers, photographs, and books can come to you. To the classroom. To the students. Through the Internet.

Archives across the world are digitizing their holdings. The ramifications of this trend on education are enormous. Students living in Oregon can “travel” to the National Archives without going to D.C. Students living in Florida can discover the history of the Pacific Northwest without leaving the sunshine state.

From a pedagogical standpoint, we speak a lot about inquiry driven education, of guiding students to find answers rather than simply giving them answers. Digital archives allows us to take this pedagogy into historical education in a whole new way.

Students can read one of FDR’s fireside chats from 1933. They can explore documents and photographs regarding the internment of Japanese Americans. They can examine propaganda from World War II. They can compare maps of Indian Territory over the years. Students can remember 9/11. They can investigate the Venona papers and explore indigenous Alaskan culture. They can read the death warrant for John J. Kehoe and find information on the Pennsylvania canal system.  They can listen to the voices of civil rights in Mississippi or read the journal of a Freedom School teacher.  

And that's just the tip of the iceberg. 



Universal Design for Learning




Created on Inspiration 8, a concept map of Universal Design for Learning *(UDL).

Inspiration is a great program. The templates alone provide a wonderful variety of graphic organizers, and I like in particular that you can go from an outline to the diagram and back again, and I would have students who had difficulty outlining use this program themselves. It's a little bit difficult to fit everything in and have it still make visual sense when there's a lot of material to cover, as in UDL.

Universal design for learning is one of those ideas that really seems so obvious, but actually takes a good deal of creativity and innovation to implement successfully. One of the thinks I was continually struck by when I was taking special education was just how much technology was used to bridge the learning gap. It's truly remarkable to think of the things we can do today that we unthinkable not all that long ago. But what I consistently thought, as we went through all the methods for adapting and accommodating the curriculum to a variety of learners is, this can help everyone. For example, for students who have speech and language disorders, classrooms and curriculum should be heavily visual, with tons of visual reinforcement for language, and should employ different learning modalities. But of course, this is good for all students! That's really the most basic idea behind UDL.

Seeing the Big Picture: Looking at the 60s Visually


One way of looking at the 60s.  Brings in literature, people, music, art, science...

Focus on Social Studies: What That Means



Just a few of the things "social studies" can mean, created in Wordle.

I'm going to use social studies as my curricular focus for the course, and in this blog.  In particular, the first content standard as described in the Connecticut Curriculum Framework for Social Studies: Students will develop historical thinking, including chronological thinking and recognizing change over time; contextualizing, comprehending and analyzing
historical literature; researching historical sources; understanding the concept of historical causation understanding competing narratives and interpretation; and constructing narratives and interpretations.

But first, I have to explain my philosophy of education a bit more, and my views of pedagogy and curriculum.  Even though that standard is my stated focus, few lessons and units can, in my view, be taught with such a narrow focus.  Learning, and the world, is by nature interdisciplinary.  Social studies units and lessons will draw on many of the things mentioned in the word cloud above.  We use reading, writing, art, music, and science to understand various aspects of history and culture and people.  

The division of awareness and understanding and learning into specialized disciplines is a development characteristic of the modern world.  In ancient times, they were looked at as parts of a whole.  Look to the Renaissance Man, the embodiment of Renaissance humanism, or the ideal of universal learning.  Today, we see a renewed push toward integrated curriculum, as a more complete way of teaching and learning.  Interdisciplinary learning is an essential tenet of my educational philosophy, so while I will focus on social studies and historical thinking, to accomplish those objectives means to draw from many other fields.  

There are so many ways that technology, including Inspiration, Photoshop, and others, can support learning in this area.  Here, here, here, and here are just some of the ways we can use digital imagery.  One of the great things about these technologies are that they can help us to bridge the gap that's created by the division of disciplines: integrating art with history, using the music of Woody Guthrie to understand music as an agent for social change, mapping out the connections of a central theme across disciplines, breaking down broad historical themes visually to see connecting threads through time...

We can use these things to support historical learning, but in a way that encourages deep, critical historical thinking - recognizing not just change over time but similarities throughout history, not just interpreting history but understanding it and its lessons.

Integrating Art with Social Studies




 "Art is the desire of a man to express himself, to record the reactions of his personality to the world he lives in." - Amy Lowell

Some really incredible pieces of art have been created through the recent development of digital art. Digital art can allow us to go places we couldn't previously, and makes art accessible to all of us (even the most artistically challenged of us).

Art speaks to us in ways words and photographs cannot, and provides another doorway for students seeking to understand an idea or concept from all sides.  "The work generates itself and ideas and progress and learning come out of doing the work in a particular way. Creative art is a learning process for the artist and not a description of what is already known."  -Gertrude Stein



 I would let students explore creating digital art from historical or current photographs that document whatever our current topic was. All of the photographs in this post have been altered in some way, using Photoshop Elements. They are all photographs I would use in a unit on migrant workers, and each tells a different story.



"Real education should consist of drawing the goodness and the best out of our own students. What better books can there be than the book of humanity?" -Cesar Chavez



Where in the World Is...

Adobe Photoshop can let us bring a little of the Carmen San Diego popularity into our own classrooms. Students can ask questions, get clues, and add pieces of the photo to try to guess where in the world they are, ultimately finding the location on a map. Combining photographs and maps is a good way to make the places on a map come alive, and it's a fun, low-pressure way for kids to learn about their world.

Have pre-saved layers of students, either individually or as a group, can allow you to quickly place your class in many places across the world. Photos can then be printed out or projected as a slide show as you progress through clues and questions. This is one of the easiest activities to do on Photoshop, once you've created and saved your layers for each of the students (or, to make life easier, the whole class).  Erasing parts of the scene doesn't require any precision, it takes only a few seconds.  

A quick, easy way to "travel" the world.





What's Wrong with This Picture? Evaluating Historical Documents...

We teach the scientific method in school.  We teach how to read.  We teach how to write.  We teach how to do math.  In all of those disciplines, we merge content with method, so that students may learn not just the what, but the how, in the hopes that their learning will continue long past when they leave our classroom.

But not in social studies.  Social studies has long been so content-focused to the point of excluding the how of it.  Did you ever learn the historical method in schools?  I didn't.  The textbooks treat history as if it were a solitary, static thing.  

The history of the world is pretty long.  It's simply not possible to cover everything in 13 years of school.  Better to give our students the tools that they may learn the history we don't get to on their own.  Evaluating historical documents, distinguishing between primary and secondary sources, and establishing the veracity and reliability of these historical documents.

Technology is a great way for us to do that.  Take a look at this picture.  It's a women's suffrage parade in 1912. What's wrong with it?   

Let the students explore it.  This is a photograph I'd use when they were accustomed to doing this, starting with more obvious errors first.  But through the evaluation of this photograph, students can explore women's suffrage, life in the early 1900s, and the invention of the car.  

Photoshop Elements makes this relatively easy.  There's a host of historical photographs available online, through the Library of Congress's American Memory, and hundreds of digital archives.  We can teach historical skills while also teaching content, and putting historical events within a context: Students learning about women's suffrage will, through evaluating this photograph, learn a little bit about life in the early 1900s: cars were just becoming widely available (like Model Ts, not Mustangs!) , the dress typical of the era, and so on.  This is important, particularly in the elementary grades, because often pieces of history are taught in such a disjointed manner that few connections are made: the invention of the car would rarely be taught near women's suffrage, despite the fact that they were occurring largely within the same time period.  

As they say, a picture is worth a thousand words.  And who wouldn't want to hear their ten-year-old students pointing out, "Hey!  That's ridiculous - they were just starting to drive Model Ts back then!  Ford developed his assembly line only four years before that!"